Vineyard

Buttonwood Grove

Cayuga Lake

Plan a wine trip to Buttonwood Grove — Femente builds the route.

Wineries54,000Wine Regions1,200Restaurants65,000
EXCELLENT · CRITICS' CONSENSUS

Finger Lakes sparkle and red blends from Cayuga Lake.

Buttonwood Grove produces wines from Cayuga Lake in New York's Finger Lakes region, where cool-climate conditions favor aromatic white varieties and structured reds. The winery's Riesling Pét-Nat—a sparkling expression of the region's signature grape—has drawn attention from major critics including Wine Enthusiast, Wine Advocate, Wine Spectator, Falstaff, and Decanter. A Big Red Blend and Melody Pét-Nat round out the portfolio, the latter showcasing the Melody variety in sparkling form. Finger Lakes viticulture emphasizes precision and freshness, qualities evident across these offerings. The pét-nat category—naturally carbonated and lower in alcohol than traditional méthode champenoise—has gained traction among wine drinkers seeking approachable, food-friendly sparkle. Buttonwood Grove's focus on this style, paired with Riesling's natural affinity for the lake's terroir, positions the winery within a growing movement of New York producers exploring both classic and experimental expressions of their region's potential.

Peak score90 / 100
RegionCayuga LakeAddress5986 State Route 89, 14541, Romulus, United States
Top winesRiesling Bubbly · Blaufrankisch · Bubbly Gewürztraminer
Nearby · within 30 min

Other wineries worth a stop near Cayuga Lake

See all in Cayuga Lake
Across the region

More in Cayuga Lake

All 4 wineries in Cayuga Lake
Are you the owner?

Claim Buttonwood Grove.

Verified venues can update their profile, respond to visitors, and curate which wines are featured. Submit a quick request — we review each one by hand.

Already convinced?

Take the trip with Femente.

One tap and the app builds the route, picks the stops, and books you in. Free during beta.