Where to go · Long Island

The Long Island wineries worth finding

54 producers in Long Island that the critics rate, ranked by where the guides place them.

54
Rated producers
93
Top score

The list

  1. 1Pindar VineyardsNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 6 criticsDISTINCTION89→
  2. 2BedellNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION91→
  3. 3Channing DaughtersLong Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION90→
  4. 4Duck Walk VineyardsLong Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION92→
  5. 5Harbes VineyardLong Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION91→
  6. 6Lenz WineryNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION93→
  7. 7Lieb CellarsLong Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION90→
  8. 8MattebellaLong Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION90→
  9. 9One WomanLong Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION90→
  10. 10Palmer VineyardsNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION91→
  11. 11PaumanokNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 5 criticsDISTINCTION92→
  12. 12Coffee Pot CellarsNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 4 criticsDISTINCTION89→
  13. 13MacariNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 4 criticsDISTINCTION89→
  14. 14Pellegrini VineyardsNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 4 criticsDISTINCTION88→
  15. 15Sannino Bella Vita VineyardNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 4 criticsDISTINCTION87→
  16. 16SchneiderNorth Fork of Long Island, United StatesRated by 4 criticsDISTINCTION87→
  17. 17Sparkling PointeLong Island, United StatesRated by 4 criticsDISTINCTION91→

How we choose

We rank by critic standing first: the guides' top tier, then critic count, then score. The ↗ Rising mark goes to producers the guides have not yet tiered that the crowd already rates in the region's top fifth, the ones worth trying before the critics catch up. More on how the list works

Frequently asked

How many wineries are in Long Island?
Femente tracks 54 critic-rated producers in Long Island, United States.
What are the best wineries in Long Island?
Top critic-rated producers in Long Island include Pindar Vineyards, Bedell, Channing Daughters, Duck Walk Vineyards, and Harbes Vineyard.
Does this use user reviews or critic ratings?
Critic ratings and our own momentum tracking only. There are no crowd star averages anywhere in the ranking.

Keep exploring

Take Long Island with you

Download on the App StoreFree · iPhone